Chief Regulator calls for Environment Agency to have “more teeth” against those falling short of high standards
Environment Agency Chief Regulator Dr Jo Nettleton recently called for the environmental regulation framework to be reformed in order to help better protect people and the environment and enable businesses to grow.
It comes as a brand-new report published by the Chief Regulator, shows that across dozens of sectors – from waste to chemicals and through to water quality – 93% of the more than 14,000 businesses are complying with their environmental permits. However, a small group of rogue operators continue to be reckless, harming their local communities, and were punished with hefty fines totalling £8.7 million over the last year.
In today’s report, Jo Nettleton has called for the Environment Agency’s regulation to go further and have “more teeth”, ensuring firm action is taken against those whose performance falls below standard so that they improve, are held to account and do not gain advantage from cutting corners.
Environment Agency’s Chief Regulator Jo Nettleton said:
“We have to strike a balance between regulation that supports good businesses and removes unnecessary burdens, but can also show more teeth in clamping down against operators who fall below the required standards.
I want to ensure the Environment Agency is holding to account those poor performers, so that they improve and do not gain advantage from cutting corners.
That is why we need reforms to the regulatory framework – enabling us to deliver the change needed to better protect communities, and the environment they thrive in, for generations to come.”
Environment Agency’s Chair Alan Lovell said:
“Our staff are at the forefront of delivering better environmental outcomes and transforming the way businesses are regulated across England.
I welcome the Chief Regulator’s report, which highlights the positive outcomes delivered across the organisation but is a stark reminder of the further progress needed to deliver for our customers, the public and environment for years to come.
Our teams will continue to collaborate with Jo over the coming year to deliver on our joint priorities, ensuring we are a more efficient regulator that is fit for the future.”
The Chief Regulator’s newly-created role is to hold the Environment Agency to account in delivering its regulatory activities and to champion best practice as part of the EA’s drive to be an open and transparent organisation.
The report also found that last year, the agency successfully shut down 63 illegal waste sites, bringing the total number in operation to 344 – the lowest total figure on record. Enforcement officers also prevented nearly 34,000 tonnes of waste from being illegally exported by waste criminals.
In the report, the Chief Regulator said:
“At the end of March 2024, the EA recorded 344 illegal waste sites as being active. This was down from 407 at the end of March 2023 and the lowest number on their records.
Despite our work on waste crime and our data showing a steady decline in active illegal waste sites, I know there is still a lot to do. Our 2023 waste crime survey estimated:
- only a quarter of waste crime is reported
- 18% of all waste is perceived as being illegally managed
- over 40% of businesses within the waste industry believe they have been affected by waste crime
The environmental and economic impact of waste crime is huge. It costs the taxpayer and economy an estimated £1 billion each year. This money is being taken away from other essential services to deal with the damage caused by waste criminals. Tackling waste crime is a priority for us as it affects the environment, local communities and legitimate businesses.
We can’t tackle waste crime alone. I want our strong relationship with the police and other agencies to continue. In 2025, we will carry on building new ways of working with partners across government to tackle waste crime.”
However, there are other areas where the performance of the industry has not been good enough. Earlier this year, 5 of the 9 water and sewerage companies were rated as requiring significant improvement, with the latest Event Duration Monitoring data showing a large rise in spills – 464,056 hours compared to 301,091 in 2022. There is now 100% coverage on storm overflows, which means more spills are recorded.
EA Action
Over the last couple of years, the agency has worked hard to improve its permitting performance by halving the queue for delivering applications and working with applicants to improve their quality. Staff will continue to improve permitting through digital transformation and further efficiency improvements.
However, the Chief Regulator is clear there are still areas for improvement, such as supporting sustainable growth for the businesses it regulates.
The recent focus on water industry performance has highlighted the need for change, with the EA driving better performance with a new approach to regulation. The Water Industry Regulation Transformation Programme, launched in 2023, sets out measures to uncover non-compliance.
This change will also be further delivered through new powers provided by the new Water (Special Measures) Bill to hold water companies and their bosses to account faster.
Regulatory Action
As evidenced in the report, the UK is one of the most nature-depleted countries in the world, and water pollution, air quality, waste management and climate change are still major challenges. However, the framework which dictates how regulators – like the Environment Agency – address this originates from the last century and is not fit to meet the challenges ahead.
The Chief Regulator is now calling for fundamental changes to this legislation, to ensure the Environment Agency and other regulators have the tools they need to meet these challenges.
By making the framework simpler and more agile, regulators will be able to provide improved environmental protections for people and the environment through quicker responses, while providing experts with the ability to tighten or reduce regulatory oversight in response to new evidence and data. Changes will also support greater innovation and deliver better value for money by simplifying internal processes and improved cost recovery.
Alongside an updated framework, Dr Nettleton wants the Environment Agency to deliver a better experience for those it regulates. This needs resilient funding, including from increased cost recovery for implementing regulations, to enable better digital services, improved customer advice, improved data-led decision making and a smoother customer experience.
Sources
www.gov.uk www.gov.uk
