Rising metal theft, driven by high copper prices, is exposing weaknesses in the Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013. Industry specialist Robin Edwards calls for legislative reform, stronger enforcement, mandatory training and a single regulatory body to improve compliance, tackle criminal activity and raise standards across the UK metal recycling sector.

As metal theft rises across the UK and copper prices hit record highs, Robin Edwards, owner of ONIS Consulting and a consultant to industry and law enforcement agencies, examines the growing threat to national infrastructure. He discusses the work of the National Infrastructure Crime Reduction Partnership (NICRP) and explains why changes to the Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013, improved enforcement and better industry training are needed to tackle crime and raise standards across the recycling sector.
Metal theft rises as copper prices climb
We sit at a crossroads as infrastructure and metal crime rises at an alarming rate, with record highs in terms of the price of copper. I can’t underestimate the scale of the problem and the threat the UK faces in these difficult times. We are seeing large-scale thefts across the country, many of which are committed by well-organised criminal gangs who are profiting from these high commodity prices. We are also seeing an increase in lower-level offending increasing as the economic strain bites and criminals see this as a solution to their problems.
To highlight the scale of the problem, we have seen a 92% increase in cable-related crime in August 2026 compared to August 2025, which is clearly linked to the 43% increase in the price of copper over the same period. There are no indicators that suggest the price of copper will fall, and it is highly likely to rise even higher, creating an even greater risk to our national and critical national infrastructure.
The growing threat to critical infrastructure
The renewable sector is being targeted, with solar and wind farms being attacked for the copper cable, which has a significant impact on our net zero economy and long-term move away from carbon fuels. Electric vehicle cables are increasingly targeted, and some providers are questioning where to place their chargers. The value of the cables will be quite low in terms of scrap value, but replacing them can be upwards of £5000 each, before we even factor in the loss of revenue and reputational damage to these companies.
The current legislation requires updating, and the loopholes that exist need closing. There is no doubt in my mind that most of the stolen metal is making its way into the recycling sector, and I have yet to see any credible evidence to the contrary. It has been suggested that material is being exported; again, until I am presented with credible evidence to support this assumption, I remain sceptical. Some may be exported, but the majority is making its way into metal recyclers.
There are some in the sector who are either willing to buy stolen material, are happy to turn a blind eye to what passes through their gates or are not willing to ask the awkward questions in terms of the provenance of the material they are buying. This needs to stop.
Training to improve compliance and tackle metal crime
Although I paint a bleak picture of the current situation, there are glimmers of hope on the horizon. The Infrastructure and Metal Crime awareness training continues to be delivered to police, licencing and affected sectors. This has been extremely successful in raising awareness and providing the skills needed to target those who are not compliant or buy stolen material.
However, there is, and always will be, an issue in terms of priorities, particularly in terms of policing, and unfortunately infrastructure and metal crime doesn’t sit on that list. I suspect this will change, but the question is, how much? The other challenge we face is the ever-changing roles within enforcement as people move into different departments and positions and new people take up their roles. Training can’t be delivered once; it needs to be an ongoing process that maintains knowledge levels in the departments that matter.
The recycling industry requires training so that they understand their roles and responsibilities when it comes to complying with the legislation. The act has been in place for thirteen years, and I suspect there has been very little training provided to the sector since it was introduced in 2013.
I have been working with a large multi-site business that has embraced the need to train their staff, not just to protect their staff and their business, but to raise the standards across the sector. The training covers their roles and responsibilities under the legislation, but also what they should do when presented with stolen or suspicious material. For example, reject it, quarantine it, who should call, what information should they retain and how to avoid conflict with those customers who want to dispose of their suspicious metal.
The training also covers the role of enforcement and the powers they have when visiting a site. This is important as it is an area that can cause unnecessary conflict, which should be avoided. There are several powers police and other agencies can use to enter a site, and there are clear rules in terms of what they can and can’t do during a visit. These are all covered in the training, and the feedback from those that have taken part has been excellent.
Why the Scrap Metal Dealers Act needs reform
The legislation, as I have said many times, is flawed and is well overdue for a review to not only close the holes that exist but also to bring it up to date.
I have been working on two elements of the legislation. The first is the content of the act itself, which requires a complete overhaul. The legislation was reviewed in 2017, and the decision was taken at that time not to make any changes or amendments to the current legislation. The decision to review the legislation in 2017 was not a well-thought-out decision. At that time, there was very little evidence supporting an update of the Act; however, in 2019 commodity prices rose, and there was no expectation they would go as high as they are today.
I was tasked to produce a list of recommendations, and without a great deal of effort I arrived at a list of fifty-one amendments. This initial list is extensive, provides a broad overview of the legislation’s shortfalls, and offers a strong starting point for a jointly supported proposal to drive legislative change. I appreciate that changing the Act isn’t going to be easy to achieve, and having been involved in the development and roll-out of the 2013 legislation, I am well versed in the task ahead. The current loopholes are being exploited, and if we want to reduce crime and raise standards across the sector, then this needs to be considered and actioned.
Rethinking licensing and enforcement
The second element is licensing under the Scrap Metal Dealers Act and the roles and responsibilities of enforcement agencies. Currently, there are significant variations when it comes to licensing fees, with each LA setting its own fee structure. This causes issues as the lower fees may not provide sufficient levels of funding for the LA to effectively carry out its statutory duty in terms of ensuring compliance with the SMDA 2013.
The current licensing requirements for Mobile Collectors are almost impossible to enforce and, from an industry perspective, comply with. Improvements in this area would reduce bureaucracy, cut costs, and make it easier for collectors to operate. All these factors impact the effectiveness of the legislation and provide evidence for change both in terms of the content of the act and in terms of who should enforce the legislation, issue licences and prosecute offenders.
Under the terms agreed in 2013, the Environmental Agencies hold the register of licences on their public register, the Local Authorities issue the licences, and the Police enforce against unlicenced dealers. This has proved not to be as effective as it was initially hoped, and a single body having responsibility for all three sections would remove many of the challenges faced currently.
The case for a single regulatory body
A single body would make it much easier to collaborate with partners, bring all their information under one roof and allow a greater degree of understanding in terms of licencing. It would enable a much more structured and cost-effective response to licencing and enforcement to be introduced. Currently, all three organisations are required to collaborate during the licensing process, and this has not really materialised in the way it was anticipated when the Act was drafted. In addition, this creates challenges and confusion around inspection, licensing, and any required enforcement activity.
The advantages of a single body are that it would reduce costs, increase licencing revenue, streamline the process, improve efficiencies in terms of the licensing process and significantly improve inspections and enforcement activity. At the simplest level, this activity would ultimately reduce the bureaucracy that currently exists with each individual LA having responsibility for their dealers, but my vision would provide a coordinated response to tackle the current challenges and deficiencies that exist across all three agencies. A single body responsible for all three areas would create significant cost efficiencies and greatly improve compliance. Not only would this provide a greater degree of oversight, it would also ensure the fees collected are used solely for inspection and enforcement activity and not diverted to cover other unrelated activity.
The next steps for the recycling sector
I continue to push my proposal forward, and the consensus from all the key stakeholders is that change is required if we are going to raise standards, reduce crime and maintain a level playing field for the sector. Those who don’t want or refuse to embrace change would find the trading environment a lot less forgiving, and ultimately that could result in businesses having licences revoked and the opportunity to trade removed.
I don’t underestimate the scale of the challenge, but it’s one I will not shy away from, and ultimately, we will see changes in terms of mandatory training for the sector as part of the licensing process, a tightening of the Act and a well-trained and sector-focused agency with the sole responsibility for managing the sector. Exciting times ahead.

About Robin Edwards
Robin Edwards is acknowledged as an expert in his field, having gained a wealth of experience in relation to the Scrap Metal Dealers Act 2013 and metal crime. Robin was the National Project Lead for Operation Tornado, Operational Lead for the National Metal Theft Taskforce and was involved in the development and delivery of the 2013 Scrap Metal Dealers Act before retiring and setting up Onis Consulting, which works with enforcement and industry to tackle metal crime. Robin currently works for British Transport Police (BTP) as a subject matter expert. He was one of the founders of the National Infrastructure Crime Reduction Partnership, which he runs as its project lead, subject matter expert and trainer. He acts as an expert advisor to enforcement agencies in the UK and sits on numerous working groups. His knowledge and expertise around metal theft is recognised internationally.
Further Reading on ATF Professional
- How NICRP and Partners Are Exposing Non-Compliance in Recycling
- BMRA – Home Office Must Act On Metal Theft
- Tackling Metal Theft: A Collaborative Approach


